Cryptanalysis of Two Candidate Fixes of Multilinear Maps over the Integers

Shortly following Cheon, Han, Lee, Ryu and Stehlé’s attack against the multilinear map of Coron, Lepoint and Tibouchi (CLT), two independent approaches to thwart this attack have been proposed on the cryptology ePrint archive, due to Garg, Gentry, Halevi and Zhandry on the one hand, and Boneh, Wu and Zimmerman on the other. In this short note, we show that both countermeasures can be defeated in polynomial time using extensions of the Cheon et al. attack.